ETF & INDEX RESEARCH
ValueETFsby LMS Solution
METHODOLOGY & EDITORIAL POLICY

How ValueETFs Calculates Valuation and Opportunity Scores

ValueETFs compares USA ETFs, Indian indices, Indian ETFs and global country-market proxies in separate dashboards. Scores summarise dated inputs; they do not estimate a guaranteed return or replace analysis of the underlying investment.

Price cheapness: what the percentages measure

High-price cheapness (%) = 100 × (reference high − current price) ÷ reference high. This applies to ATH, three-year, five-year and 52-week high references. The ATH label describes available source history, not a guarantee of the true lifetime intraday high.

200-DMA cheapness (%) = 100 × (reference moving average − current price) ÷ reference moving average. Positive means below the average; negative means above it. These are price relationships, not discounts to intrinsic value or historical P/E ratios.

Relative P/E cheapness (%) = 100 × (peer median P/E − instrument P/E) ÷ peer median P/E. P/B uses the equivalent formula. Yield attractiveness (%) = 100 × (instrument yield − peer median yield) ÷ peer median yield. Eligibility checks and peer groups depend on the market model. Sector composition and accounting definitions can affect comparability.

USA: adaptive valuation weights

Base valuation weights for USA and global models
InputWeight
ATH / available-history high discount13⅓%
Three-year high discount13⅓%
Five-year high discount13⅓%
200-DMA discount10%
52-week high discount10%
Relative P/E cheapness20%
Yield attractiveness20%

USA inputs are capped between −100 and +100 points. Raw adaptive score is the weighted mean of eligible available inputs; remaining weights are renormalised. Commodity and Real Assets categories exclude the P/E and yield components, so five price measures are applicable instead of seven.

USA final adjusted score = raw adaptive score × data completeness. Completeness is available divided by applicable metrics, as a fraction between zero and one. The current separate history-penalty term is zero. History confidence is still displayed, but it is not an additional multiplier in this USA valuation formula.

India: three valuation components and explicit penalties

Available component weights are renormalised. Final valuation score = raw valuation score − 10 × (1 − completeness) − 5 × (1 − history confidence). History confidence is 100% at five years or more, 90% at three to under five years, 75% at one to under three years, and 60% below one year.

The India coverage count includes five price metrics, twelve performance/risk metrics and three fundamentals: normally 20 applicable inputs, or 17 for commodity categories. Missing applicable inputs reduce coverage. An unavailable price basis is not treated as a scored instrument.

Risk-adjusted performance: exact base weights

Weights used by the USA and India risk/performance models
MetricWeightModel direction
One-year return5%Higher percentile
Three-year CAGR10%Higher percentile
Five-year CAGR10%Higher percentile
Annualised volatility8%Lower percentile
Beta5%Lower percentile
Sharpe ratio12%Higher percentile
Jensen alpha12%Higher percentile
Downside deviation8%Lower percentile
Sortino ratio12%Higher percentile
Benchmark correlation5%Lower percentile
Maximum drawdown8%Higher / less-negative percentile
Calmar ratio5%Higher percentile

Each available measure is converted to a cross-sectional percentile. The weighted mean is rescaled to 0–100, with missing-input weights removed. At least three measures are required. Lower beta and correlation are model preferences, not universal definitions of a better fund.

The benchmark is SPY for USA calculations and Nifty 50 for India. Current configured annual risk-free assumptions are 4% and 6%, respectively; they are model assumptions, not live bond quotations. Weekly close observations are used for historical calculations. Price-based returns may exclude distributions and differ from an issuer's total-return figures.

Volatility is weekly-return standard deviation × √52. The model's downside-deviation field is the annualised standard deviation of negative weekly returns; this differs from target-based downside-deviation definitions. Sharpe and Sortino use three-year CAGR less the configured risk-free rate divided by their respective volatility fields. Maximum drawdown is the worst observed close-to-running-peak loss in the measured series. Calmar is three-year CAGR divided by absolute maximum drawdown.

Combined opportunity score: 60% valuation, 40% risk/performance

USA: 60% × valuation percentile + 40% × risk/performance score. The valuation percentile compares final adjusted scores with records at the same completeness level. If a percentile cannot be calculated, its fallback is 50. If risk/performance is absent, the valuation percentile is used alone.

India: the available-weight 60/40 blend of valuation percentile and risk/performance is multiplied by √(completeness × history confidence). Missing history confidence uses a 50% fallback for this multiplier. The India percentile pool spans the source model's index and ETF universe; website displays keep the two segments separate.

Opportunity bands are Top Opportunity at ≥80, Attractive at ≥65, Neutral at ≥45, Weak at ≥30, and Low Opportunity below 30. USA incomplete records are labelled Partial Data rather than a complete-data opportunity band.

Complete-record valuation bands are Very Cheap at ≥20, Cheap at ≥10, Fair above −10 and below 10, Expensive above −20 through −10, and Very Expensive at ≤−20. USA incomplete valuation records are labelled Partial Valuation. India applies the thresholds to its penalised final score. These labels are model classifications, not buy or sell instructions.

Source ranks can prioritise coverage; a dashboard's selected sorting can instead order by a chosen metric. A percentile changes when the comparison universe changes, even if an instrument's own fundamentals do not.

Global markets: seven-metric model and coverage-first ranks

Global markets outside USA and India use country ETF proxies and the seven base weights shown above. Raw score is the weighted mean of available capped inputs; adjusted score = raw score × coverage. All seven remain applicable. P/B is displayed for reference and excluded from this score.

Issuer P/E and yield older than the current 90-day limit are excluded from eligibility and peer medians. Rankings prioritise higher coverage, then adjusted score; ties retain source order. Incomplete records use partial/no-data labels rather than full valuation bands. Proxy holdings can differ from a country's headline index, and USD price history includes currency effects.

Sources, privacy, coverage and refresh rules

Price/history inputs use Google Finance where available. Fundamental inputs are maintained from dated fund-issuer information and, for Indian indices, official NSE Indices snapshots and reports. Source coverage and definitions vary by instrument. Review fundamentals dates, resolved symbols, direct-index versus proxy price basis and metric applicability.

The backend reads private source workbooks through authenticated, read-only access. Public pages expose selected market fields and accepted snapshots; they do not expose workbook identifiers or credentials. The website does not recalculate the source scores.

Ranking-average acceptance rules
MarketAccept new data only above
USA85% data completeness
India indices and ETFs79% data completeness
Global excluding USA and India95% coverage

These are strict greater-than tests on the mean of named ranking entries. Missing completeness counts as zero. They are whole-snapshot acceptance rules, not a guarantee that each row is complete. Other schema, row-count and applicable freshness checks can reject a candidate. USA candidates older than the accepted snapshot are not accepted as new data.

The page checks approximately every 60 seconds while open, and the backend limits refresh attempts. A check time is not a source-data time. Incomplete or failed source reads retain a prior accepted snapshot, which can be older. Quotes, history, fundamentals and accepted snapshots have distinct dates. N/A means unavailable or non-applicable, never zero.

Editorial standards, ownership and corrections

ValueETFs is published by LMS Solution. ValueETFs Editorial is the organisation's editorial attribution, not a named licensed financial adviser. Articles provide education and explanatory analysis; they do not provide personalised recommendations or guaranteed market forecasts.

Our publication process checks source identity, observation dates, units, price basis and calculations. We distinguish reported observations, third-party forecasts and editorial scenarios, and preserve publication dates when substantive updates are made. AI-assisted writing and conceptual imagery may be used; generated imagery is not a source of market measurements.

Advertising may appear on the site. An advertising placement does not establish our endorsement of a product. No professional credential, independent audit or backtested performance claim is implied by the scoring system.

For a correction, email support@lmssolution.net with the URL, instrument, metric, displayed date and supporting source. See our contact details and Privacy Policy.

Scores and historical relationships do not predict returns. Models can be sensitive to missing data, price adjustments, differing definitions, stale inputs and changes in their comparison universe. Check original issuer documents and consider qualified advice for personal investment decisions.